Where to Buy Used Jigsaw Puzzles to Save Money: Your Ultimate Guide

Do you buy used jigsaw puzzles? If you do, you know it could save your bank account some serious bucks.

As someone who loves jigsaw puzzles, I’m going to share some fantastic tips and tricks on where to buy used jigsaw puzzles not only to save money, but also to find puzzles that you might never otherwise get the chance to enjoy completing.

Why Buy Used Jigsaw Puzzles?

First off, why even consider buying used puzzles? I don’t know about you, but any fun puzzle to assemble is the best part of the day. Well, there are several reasons I buy used jigsaw puzzles:

Buy Used Jigsaw Puzzles

Cost Savings

New puzzles can be pretty pricey, especially if you’re a frequent puzzler. Buying used jigsaw puzzles can save you a significant amount of money. My husband always gives a big thumbs up over this idea!

Eco-Friendly

Buying used means you’re giving a second life to something that might otherwise end up in a landfill. It’s a small but meaningful way to contribute to sustainability.

Variety

You might find unique or out-of-print puzzles that aren’t available in stores anymore. This can add some rare gems to your collection. I’ve had more fun with used puzzles than I care to share.

Now, let’s explore some of the best places to find these hidden gems!

Where to Buy Jigsaw Puzzles that are Used (Yet Complete)

1. Thrift Stores: The Treasure Hunt

Thrift stores are like a goldmine for puzzle lovers. These places are often filled with donated items, including jigsaw puzzles, at incredibly low prices. There are even thrift store chains that highlight games, jigsaw puzzles and board games. What I always tell people is that you can find great puzzles here, but you need to be vigilant to find the best used jigsaw puzzles.

Here’s what you need to do:

  • Check Regularly: Inventory changes frequently, so make a habit of stopping by your local thrift store every week or so. This increases your chances of finding new items. I know some people who go every other day to check out the puzzles and they find some great ones too!
  • Inspect the Box: Make sure the box looks intact and not too worn out. Check for any obvious signs of damage or watermarks. Take your time to do it right. Don’t feel like you need to rush for this action.
  • Piece Count: If possible, check if the puzzle pieces are bagged inside. This can save you from the heartbreak of missing pieces. Sometimes thrift stores allow you to open the box to verify the contents, but if not, you can always ask. I’ve had employees help me count the pieces and I couldn’t have been more grateful!

2. Online Marketplaces: Convenience at Your Fingertips

The internet is your best friend when it comes to finding used puzzles. Several years back I was sick and couldn’t leave the house. Finding puzzles online was my only option. There are several online marketplaces where you can score some great deals:

eBay

eBay is a fantastic place to find used puzzles. I always look for jigsaw puzzles in bundles. This means you don’t get slammed for postage as more than one puzzle is worth it! You can bid on auctions or buy directly from sellers. I prefer the latter and I always send in an offer before I buy. Typically people want people to buy used jigsaw puzzles so they will lower the price. Here are some tips:

  • Use Filters: Narrow down your search by using filters like price range, condition, and seller location. This helps you find exactly what you’re looking for more quickly.
  • Read Reviews: Check the seller’s reviews and ratings to ensure they have a good track record. Look for sellers with high ratings and positive feedback.
  • Ask Questions: Don’t hesitate to ask the seller about the condition of the puzzle or if all pieces are included. Most sellers are happy to provide additional photos or details.

Facebook Marketplace

Facebook Marketplace is another excellent option. It’s local, which means you might be able to pick up your puzzle and avoid shipping fees. Who knows? You might even find another puzzle person that loves puzzles as much as you do or loves to play speed puzzling.

  • Set Alerts: You can set alerts for keywords like “jigsaw puzzle” so you get notified when new listings pop up. This way, you can be one of the first to see new items on Facebook and can respond quick.
  • Negotiate: Don’t be shy to negotiate the price. Most sellers are willing to haggle a bit. Always be polite and respectful in your communication.

3. Garage Sales: The Unexpected Finds

Never underestimate the potential of a good old garage sale. I especially like community sales, neighborhood sales and any sale that has more than one family. I’ve come to expect a few puzzles from these types of sales. These can be hit or miss, but when you hit, you often hit big.

  • Plan Your Route: Use apps or websites that list garage sales in your area. Plan a route to maximize your stops and make the most efficient use of your time.
  • Early Bird Gets the Worm: The best items are usually snapped up early, so try to get there as soon as the sale starts. Bring small bills and change for easier transactions.
  • Bundle Deals: If the seller has multiple puzzles, ask for a bundle deal. This can save you even more money. Sellers are often more willing to negotiate if you’re buying several items at once.

4. Puzzle Swaps and Clubs: Community Spirit

Joining a puzzle swap group or club can be a fun and social way to get new puzzles. I will say that this is my least effective way to getting awesome puzzles. Typically I find that puzzle swapping is a difficult thing as people expect you to report back on how you liked/loved the puzzle. I’d rather buy puzzles from strangers and have an experience that is unique.

  • Local Libraries and Community Centers: Many local libraries and community centers host puzzle swap events. You bring in puzzles you’re done with and swap them for new ones. It’s also a great way to meet other puzzle enthusiasts in your area.
  • Online Groups: There are many Facebook groups and forums dedicated to puzzle swapping. Just join the group, follow the rules, and start swapping! Make sure to read group guidelines to ensure smooth transactions.

5. Used Bookstores: The Hidden Gems

Used bookstores often carry more than just books. Many have a section for games and puzzles. You might even find they hold puzzle competition events too. This is an unknown but awesome way to buy used great jigsaw puzzles. Here’s how to make the most of your visit:

  • Ask the Staff: Sometimes puzzles are tucked away in corners. Don’t be afraid to ask if they have any in stock. Staff members can also tell you when they usually get new stock.
  • Check Regularly: Just like thrift stores, their inventory can change frequently. Bookmark your favorite stores and visit often.

6. Flea Markets: The Bargain Hunter’s Paradise

Flea markets are another fantastic place to find used puzzles. I’ve found more vintage puzzles at flea markets than I can count on both hands. What I noticed is that a flea market crowd isn’t a jigsaw puzzle crowd, so when you find jigsaw puzzles, they will literally slash prices to get rid of the puzzles. These markets are often filled with vendors selling a variety of second-hand goods, including jigsaw puzzles.

  • Haggle: Prices at flea markets are usually negotiable. Don’t be afraid to haggle to get the best deal. Practice your bargaining skills and always be polite.
  • Inspect Carefully: Make sure to check the condition of the puzzle box and ask the seller if all pieces are included. If the seller allows, you can open the box to ensure everything is in order.

Tips for Buying Used Puzzles

You can’t be looking for jigsaw puzzles and not get good deals! To ensure you get the best deals on used puzzles, I’ve got a few tips to make your next trip successful. Yes, buy used jigsaw puzzles, but get a deal!

  • Condition: Always check the condition of the puzzle. Look for any signs of wear or damage. A slightly worn box is okay, but damaged pieces are a no-go. Don’t feel pressured as you will be disappointed later.
  • Piece Count: Try to verify that all pieces are included. This isn’t always possible, but it’s worth asking. Some sellers might offer a partial refund if pieces are missing, but it’s better to check beforehand. Many times people say the pieces are there, but they are not. Ask to count the pieces if you are paying a fair price.
  • Price Comparison: Compare prices across different platforms and sellers to ensure you’re getting the best deal. Don’t rush into a purchase; take your time to find the best offer. And remember, people who love jigsaw puzzles also buy used jigsaw puzzles so they know a deal too.

My Comprehensive Guide: It’s all My Experience

So, there you have it, my friend, this is how I buy used jigsaw puzzles. My comprehensive guide to buying used jigsaw puzzles and saving money is 100% my experiences. You see many people want a great deal when they buy used jigsaw puzzles and it’s definitely possible. Whether you’re scouring thrift stores, browsing online marketplaces, or hitting up garage sales, there are plenty of ways to find affordable puzzles.

Plus, it’s a fun and eco-friendly way to keep your puzzle collection growing without spending a fortune. Enjoy your new-to-you assembling units next time you buy used jigsaw puzzles!